Search St. John Homes

Discover St. John, Indiana

Explore the community, discover local events and find your next home with Adam Hickenbottom of McColly Real Estate.

Community Life and Recreation

St. John offers neighborhood parks, recreational programs, community activities and seasonal events. Explore local parks and check official town information for upcoming events.

Explore Local Parks»Community Events Calendar»

St. John Real Estate Market Snapshot

A snapshot of active St. John residential MLS listings checked October 15, 2026.

94Active Listings
$772,550Average Asking Price
$243Average Price / Sq. Ft.
4Average Bedrooms

Current Asking Price Compared With Available Homes

Lowest Asking Price$230,000
Average Asking Price$772,550
Highest Asking Price$1,947,700

Active asking-price figures, not sold-price averages. Figures are dated and do not automatically update. Days on market requires verified listing-history data.

Schools, Services and Local Planning

School attendance areas, transportation routes, tax assessments and services depend on the specific property. Verify details with the relevant agencies.

Find Your Next Home in St. John

Explore live homes for sale below, or contact Adam Hickenbottom of McColly Real Estate and Team TVGRE for property guidance.

Contact Your Agent Adam | Search Northwest Indiana Homes

Make Your St. John Home Search Easier

Tell Adam what you're looking for and request personalized updates, or explore your home's potential value.

Save My Home SearchAsk Adam to help track matching homesGet New Listing AlertsRequest updates on St. John homesWhat's My Home Worth?Explore home-selling and valuation options

Explore St. John Homes by Price

Choose your price range to browse live St. John MLS homes. Some ranges may currently have no available listings.

$1 Million+Luxury HomesView available homes »$100K - $300KEntry-Level OptionsView available homes »$300K - $500KPopular Price RangeView available homes »$500K - $700KMove-Up HomesView available homes »$700K - $1 MillionUpper-Tier HomesView available homes »

Homes for Sale in St. John

8315 Meadow Lane, St. John
$1,947,700
4 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths
Presenting an extraordinary gated custom estate, originally built as the developer's personal residence and crafted with architectural detail and timeless elegance rarely found at any price. A grand gated approach leads into a dramatic foyer and an interior defined by rich cherry wood trim, custom glazing, solid-core doors, handcrafted beams, Amish-crafted millwork, and remarkable ceiling treatments in every room, including a stunning coffered Crawford-style cherry wood ceiling and a hand-painted cloud ceiling in the primary suite. Three fireplaces, custom built-ins, and radiant heated floors fed by a boiler-fed hydronic system with individual thermostats in every room extend throughout the main level. All four bedrooms are on the main level. The kitchen features imported Italian stone flooring, premium Bremtown maple cabinetry, and a redesigned pantry. A full wet bar with ice maker and dual refrigerators serves the main living area. De Giulio cabinetry in the laundry and office reinforces the continuity of quality. The primary suite is a luxurious private retreat with spa-inspired bath, soaking tub, walk-in shower, and custom cabinetry. The heated 4-car garage has been transformed into a custom Chicago Cubs man cave with built-in wet bar and cabinetry. A substantial upper level loft is ideal as a private retreat or media room. A three-seasons room with fireplace and HVAC overlooks the extraordinary grounds. The basement offers a wine cellar, lounge, and full kitchen, with 3,058 sq ft of bonus space beyond. Outside, botanical garden-like landscaping, Colorado boulders, a custom paver driveway, and a gated water-surrounded setting create rare beauty and privacy. At 7,881 sq ft and 247/sq ft, you cannot build this home for 2 million in 2026. 33-panel solar, electric bills as low as 14/mo. 50-year roof, 3 years old. This is not just a home. It is a legacy estate.

8315 Meadow Lane, St. John
10092 Tall Grass Trail, St. John
$1,899,900
8 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths
Experience elevated living in this extraordinary custom-designed estate inspired by sophisticated California architecture, perfectly situated on 1.35 private acres with over 6,000 finished square feet of thoughtfully curated living space. Every detail reflects modern luxury, innovation, and timeless design. The dramatic great room showcases over 20-foot ceilings, a striking fireplace, and walls of windows that flood the home with natural light, creating a seamless indoor-outdoor feel. Ten-foot ceilings, impressive 8-foot hardwood doors, and waterproof hardwood flooring enhance the home's grand yet livable design. The chef's kitchen is a true showpiece featuring extra-thick quartz countertops with ambient lighting, premium finishes, and a stunning slat-wood hidden pantry concealed behind a custom architectural door. Built-in lockers with individual charging stations add everyday convenience with elevated style. The luxurious owner's suite offers a private retreat with heated floors, standalone soaking tub, integrated bidet, and an expansive custom walk-in shower with dual shower heads. Additional upper bedrooms share a beautifully designed Jack-and-Jill bath with dual sinks. The finished walk-out lower level expands living and entertaining space with a second full kitchen featuring quartz countertops, a second fireplace, additional bedrooms, custom cabinetry, and multiple baths -- ideal for guests or multigenerational living. The heated four-car garage features extra-tall ceilings designed for vehicle lifts, Nest climate control, EV wiring, TV setup, dual-temperature water faucet, and floor drain for year-round functionality. Professionally landscaped grounds highlight a custom patio with fireplace and outdoor kitchen with granite countertops, creating a resort-style setting. A whole-home generator adds comfort and peace of mind. Integrated IT system with built in wifi range extenders.

10092 Tall Grass Trail, St. John
9660 Sweetspire Avenue, St. John
$1,450,000
5 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths
BRICK BEAUTY NOW UNDER CONSTRUCTION IN THE PRESERVE OF ST JOHN! Don't miss this stunning 5000+ sq ft home on an executive walk out lot in Phase 8 of The Preserve. Enter the foyer through 8' double front door and take in the 10' ceilings and stunning custom finishes. The inviting large office just off the foyer has French doors and hand crafted built-in cabinetry to keep things tidy. A convenient powder room is perfectly located just off the foyer too. From the foyer, walk into the 23x19 great room & primary kitchen area. Floor to ceiling custom cabinetry & large island blend perfectly w/loads of recessed lighting provide a sleek aesthetic while the cozy fireplace provides a homey touch. Then step into the 14' butler pantry/prep kitchen & appreciate every home chef's dream. An additional kitchen space complete w/ built in cabinetry & quartz counters matching the primary kitchen, an additional built in oven/microwave & apron sink providing the perfect place for kitchen storage. Just off the primary kitchen is the 20x14 dining room w/oversized Andersen 400 series windows & 8' patio door accessing the covered deck w/ tongue & groove wood ceiling. Enjoy the expansive rear yard view from 10' up! Enter from the 3+ car garage & kick off your shoes in the 10x11 mudroom w/storage closet & bench w/lockers. Then step into the center hallway & check out the main level, 5th bedroom ensuite, w/walk in tile shower, perfect for nanny or granny! The open staircase leads up to 4 generous bedrooms. Primary suite includes 24x18 bedroom, 19x14 spa bath w/glass enclosed rain shower & 16x16 closet/dressing room w/built in shelving. Bedrooms 2 & 3 share a jack & jill bath & each has a walk in closet & 12 x 10 alcove. And bedroom 4 is an ensuite w/full bath. Upper level laundry comes complete w/additional storage cabinetry, sink & granite counters. The potential of this home extends to the 10' walk out basement w/loads of west facing windows to let the sunshine in.

9660 Sweetspire Avenue, St. John
9620 Creekview Drive, St. John
$1,375,000
6 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths
DO NOT MISS THIS NEW CONSTRUCTION located on an oversized WALK OUT lot in The Preserve of St John, IN! Enjoy panoramic meadow views and no backyard neighbors on this exquisite homesite. Ready to live large? Enter this 7000+ sq ft brick beauty graced by custom 8' front entry door and know that you've arrived somewhere special. Greeted by an inviting 2 story foyer flanked by a formal dining room and office, you will appreciate the quality craftsmanship and fine finishes. Marvel at the abundant chef's kitchen which includes a large center island and butler pantry complete with it's own cabinetry, apron sink and built in microwave/wall oven combination. The great room with it's soaring 2 story ceiling and wood burning masonry fireplace with brick chimney, surrounded by large sun filled windows will transform your mood after a hectic day. Relax in the 16' x 12' sunroom or enjoy the natural beauty of the surroundings from the covered deck off the sunroom. Main level guest suite has private 3/4 bath and large closet. 8' main level interior doors accentuate the 10' ceilings and 7' engineered wood flooring throughout the main level completes this beautifully flowing floorplan. Dreams come true in the huge primary suite bedroom with fireplace and measuring 25x18, including a spa bath, with free-standing tub and glass-enclosed shower. Bedrooms 2 & 3 have walk in closets and share a jack and jill bathroom with double vanity and bedroom 4 is an ensuite with full bath & walk in closet. The heated oversized 3 car garage comes complete smart OHD openers, and hot and cold water. Custom tile surrounds for all tubs, showers & flooring in all 5 bathrooms. Then head downstairs & marvel at the 2200 sf finished basement with a 6th bedroom, huge greatroom complete with a second masonry fireplace and kitchen/dinette area. Perfect for related living! Interior photos are of a recently completed home w/the same floorplan by the same builder.

9620 Creekview Drive, St. John
8645 W 105th Avenue, St. John
$1,349,900
5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths
Build the home you've been dreaming of in the highly desirable Gates of St. John! This stunning 1.5-story custom home is perfectly situated on a beautiful homesite and is designed with luxury, comfort, and modern living in mind. Offering 5 bedrooms, 4.5 baths, and nearly 4,000 sq ft of finished living space, this exceptional residence will feature an impressive array of amenities and thoughtful details throughout. The open-concept design creates an inviting flow for everyday living and entertaining, while the spacious layout provides plenty of room for everyone. Step outside to enjoy a beautiful covered back porch--perfect for relaxing, entertaining, and extending your living space through the seasons. Best of all, there is still time to make this home truly your own! Select finishes and personalize the details to reflect your style and vision. This is your opportunity to create a one-of-a-kind custom home in one of St. John's sought-after communities. *PROPOSED CONSTRUCTION*

8645 W 105th Avenue, St. John
9670 Creekview Drive, St. John
$1,299,900
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths
This proposed construction home offers the flexibility to truly make it your own. You may choose to build using this beautifully designed plan, or bring your own custom plan to create the dream home you've always envisioned. The opportunity is yours to tailor every detail to your lifestyle, preferences, and vision. This home is nestled against a backdrop of untouched natural beauty, this proposed new construction home blends modern luxury with serene privacy. With no backyard neighbors and a stunning walkout basement overlooking mature trees, wildlife, and a must-see stunning sunset, this property delivers a true peaceful retreat. Step inside to soaring high ceilings, expansive windows, and an open concept layout that floods every room with natural light. The heart of the home is a chef ready kitchen featuring high end stainless steel appliances, sleek quartz countertops, and generous workspace perfect for cooking, hosting, or simply enjoying the view. This home features four spacious bedrooms, each designed with comfort and functionality in mind. Every bedroom includes its own walk in closet, offering exceptional storage and organization. The spa like primary suite is a true sanctuary -- complete with a large soaking tub, walk in shower, premium finishes, and thoughtful design that elevates everyday routines. The full, unfinished walkout basement provides endless possibilities: a future home gym, entertainment space, workshop, or multi generational living area. With direct access to nature and abundant natural light, it's a rare blank canvas ready for your vision. Every detail of this 3,724 sq ft residence is crafted for comfort, style, and long term enjoyment. From premium materials to thoughtful layout, this home offers the perfect blend of modern living and peaceful surroundings.

9670 Creekview Drive, St. John
9630 Sweetspire Avenue, St. John
$1,279,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths
Enjoy overlooking the expansive green view from loads of Andersen 400 series windows in this brand new 4200+ square foot 2story in the highly desirable Preserve Subdivision of St John. Built on one of the few remaining walk out lots this 2 story beauty features 4 bedroom suites upstairs including a huge primary with an amazing walk in closet/dressing room and spa bath, bedroom 4 ensuite and bedrooms 2 and 3 with jack & Jill bath. Upper level laundry with built=in cabinetry and landry sink. Upper level catwalk overlooking the greatroom and foyer below add great drama! The main level includes spaces for formal dining, office or living room, generous kitchen with it's own butler pantry/prep kitchen with additional cabinetry and wall oven/microwave. The large center island is perfect for everything from homework night to an ample space for gathering on party night. Just off the kitchen is a nice size mud room complete with coat closet and built-in bench with lockers. Just off the great room you'll also find bedroom 5 adjacent to the main level 3/4 bath-a perfect place for a guest room or play room. And just in case you need more room There is a ready to finish full walk out basement complete with rough in plumbing for future bath, egress windows for future bedrooms and 9' ceilings. Currently at drywall stage, this home can be ready in 3-4 months but there is still time to choose many finishes if you hurry!

9630 Sweetspire Avenue, St. John
8826 Schafer Drive, St. John
$1,190,000
5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths
First time on the market, this spectacular executive residence has been meticulously maintained by its original owners and offers exceptional privacy at the end of a no thru street. Set on a beautifully landscaped half acre, this 5-bedroom, 5 bath, 1-1/2 story home features over 6,500 sq ft of refined living space with premium finishes throughout. A grand foyer with motorized chandelier and curved staircase leads to a private office with coffered ceiling, an elegant dining room with built in buffet, and a stunning great room with volume ceilings, dual 8 ft sliders, preacher cabinet and gas fireplace. The gourmet kitchen impresses with an expansive island, custom cabinetry, Sub Zero refrigerator/freezer, Wolf 48" double range, Bosch dishwasher (new 2026), Sharp drawer microwave, warming drawer, granite counters, pantry, main and prep sinks, and adjoining breakfast and hearth rooms. The main floor primary suite offers volume ceilings, custom walk-in closet, and a spa inspired bath with soaker tub, glass block shower, dual vanity, and private access to the patio with newer Pentair salt water hot tub (serviced July 2026). A well-appointed laundry room includes commercial washer/dryer, sink, folding area, dog wash, beverage fridge, and ice maker. Upstairs are three oversized bedrooms--one with ensuite bath and walk in closet, and two sharing a Jack and Jill bath. The finished basement adds a large recreation area, full kitchenette with oven, microwave, 2-drawer dishwasher, ice maker, and pantry, plus a bedroom, full bath, and dedicated storage room with shelving. Outdoor amenities include a covered patio, 1620 stone matched shed, 2020 fenced dog run, sprinkler system, and mature privacy. Additional features: Brazilian walnut hardwood floors, central vacuum, reverse osmosis, gutter guards, sideload 3 car garage with poly floor coating, two new furnaces (2020), and two new A/C units (2025), city water and sewers and no HOA.

8826 Schafer Drive, St. John
9606 Fescue Drive, St. John
$1,150,000
6 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths
Be amazed when you see this gorgeous 6 bedroom, 5 bath 2 story home on an oversized gently wooded lot in The Preserve of St John! Make a grand entrance into the 2 story foyer from 8' custom double doors and take in surrounding home office, formal dining room and stunning 2 story great room with loads of natural sunlight streaming in through Andersen 400 series windows. The upper level catwalk traverses the foyer and great room and provides a gorgeous focal point of the rooms below. Then step into the massive 26 x 17 kitchen with center island, eating area and walk in pantry and check out the loads of custom cabinetry stunning backsplash and amazing appliances. Exit from the kitchen area to the covered rear patio, wired for entertainment and complete with recessed lighting in a stunning tongue and groove ceiling. Bonus main level guest bedroom and bathroom, just off the great room adds flexibility for out of towners and visitors! Or if more room is needed check out the full finished basement, an entire living space in it's own right, including a kitchenette, 3/4 bath, workout room and 6th bedroom. Then head upstairs and luxuriate in the primary en suite with it's own dressing room, spa bathroom and additional walk in closet. 2 roomy upper level bedrooms with walk in closets sharing a generous bath with huge vanity and double bowl sink. Bedroom 4 is an en suite with full bath and walk in closet. Come in from the ample 3 car, heated garage which has epoxy floors to keep things tidy and find yourself in the roomy mudroom complete with a large coat closet and bench with lockers just off the kitchen which makes it a perfect welcome home spot.

9606 Fescue Drive, St. John
9635 Switch Grass Lane, St. John
$1,150,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths
Luxury 4-Bedroom Home with Stunning Architectural Details with Serene Views. Step into luxury with this custom-designed 4-bedroom, 4-bathroom home, perfectly situated on nearly half an acre. This exquisite residence boasts a thoughtfully designed open-concept layout, blending elegance and functionality for modern living. From the moment you enter, you'll be captivated by the vaulted, trayed, and cathedral ceilings, adding depth and grandeur to the living spaces. The gourmet kitchen is a chef's dream, featuring stainless steel appliances, custom cabinetry, and premium finishes. The upper spacious bonus room offers endless possibilities, whether you need a media room, playroom, or additional guest space. The luxurious primary suite is a true retreat, complete with a spa-inspired ensuite bathroom and walk-in closet. An additional dedicated office space provides the perfect work-from-home setup. With four full bathrooms, comfort and convenience are ensured for family and guests alike. Outside, enjoy the covered 289 sq ft front and 489 sq ft rear porches on a Trex Deck, perfect for relaxing while taking in the scenic surroundings. The oversized garage provides ample space for vehicles, storage, and more. Located in a highly desirable area, this home offers a rare combination of space, style, and serenity. Don't miss this opportunity!

9635 Switch Grass Lane, St. John
13460 Camas Drive, St. John
$1,139,500
6 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths
Welcome home to luxury living in this expansive ranch with finished walkout basement in The Preserve of St. John! Offering 6 bedrooms, 4.5 baths, and nearly 5,000 finished square feet, this exceptional home combines elegant design with incredible indoor and outdoor living. The open-concept main level features soaring ceilings with rustic beams, hardwood floors, a chef's kitchen with oversized quartz island, premium appliances, double ovens, and a stunning glass-enclosed wine display. The luxurious primary suite includes a spa-inspired bath with soaking tub, custom shower, and walk-in closet. The fully finished walkout basement is an entertainer's dream with a custom sports bar, spacious recreation area, two additional bedrooms, and an extraordinary wine room. Outside, enjoy your private backyard retreat featuring an in-ground pool with waterslide, covered pavilion with fireplace and TV, outdoor kitchen, expansive patios, and beautiful views. A rare opportunity to own one of St. John's premier luxury homes.

13460 Camas Drive, St. John
9480 Tall Grass Trail, St. John
$1,100,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths
Picture yourself pulling into the driveway after a long day, taking a deep breath, and realizing you're finally home. This isn't just another house it's the place where life feels a little slower, a little richer, and a lot more rewarding. Where mornings begin with coffee on the covered patio, weekends are filled with friends and family, and evenings end in a space designed for comfort, connection, and unforgettable memories. Imagine hosting holiday gatherings that everyone looks forward to, celebrating life's biggest milestones, or simply enjoying the quiet satisfaction of owning a home you've worked so hard to achieve. Every room has been thoughtfully designed to make everyday living feel extraordinary. You didn't work this hard just to settle. You deserve a home that reflects everything you've accomplished and everything you're still building toward. At 9480 Tall Grass Trail , you'll find the perfect blend of luxury, craftsmanship, and functionality. The open concept design creates an effortless flow for entertaining, while the spacious living areas provide room to relax, recharge, and enjoy every season of life. Whether you're preparing meals in the beautifully appointed kitchen, unwinding in your private owner's suite, or envisioning the possibilities of the additional living space, this home was built to fit your lifestyle not the other way around. Step outside and enjoy the peace of one of St. John's most desirable communities, where beautifully maintained surroundings and convenient access to shopping, dining, parks, and top rated schools create the lifestyle you've been searching for. With an easy commute to downtown Chicago, you truly can have the best of both worlds. The best homes aren't defined by square footage they're defined by the life you create inside them. Years from now, you won't remember the paperwork or moving day. You'll remember the celebrations.

9480 Tall Grass Trail, St. John
Start Your Search

Updated . Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.